Share

Briefing: What Are Return Hubs and Why Are They Incompatible with Human Rights?

Summary

Return hubs have long been discussed by EU member states as a further measure to outsource refugee protection. A new Briefing shows, that they are legally fragile.
Briefing   Borderlines   Return Hubs   2026
Briefing Borderlines Return Hubs 2026. Our Visual Policy

As early as March 2025, the European Commission therefore presented a draft for a new Return Regulation intended to provide a legal framework for these deportation centers outside the EU. Two weeks ago, on March 9, 2026, the European Parliament’s Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice, and Home Affairs (LIBE Committee) presented new “Alternative Compromise Amendments” with the support of the right and far-right, which is even more restrictive than the Commission’s draft. Before trilogue negotiations between the Commission, the Council, and the Parliament can begin, the Parliament must still formally vote on the draft.

But what exactly are return hubs, what is the current legal situation under European law, and what does the draft of the new Return Regulation propose regarding them? Our briefing answers these questions in a clear and accessible manner.

At the same time, we demonstrate which human rights standards must apply—and why return hubs cannot possibly meet them: Deported asylum seekers face a violation of the principle of non-refoulement and detention in prison-like conditions. The protection of particularly vulnerable individuals cannot be guaranteed—and access to effective legal protection within the hubs is systematically restricted for everyone.

Our conclusion: From a human rights perspective, return hubs add a new dimension to the externalization of refugee protection that is unacceptable.

Find the full briefing here.

Share
Related Resources
  • What are Return Hubs and why are they incompatible with Human Rights?
    Briefings on Migration & Human Rights

    Return hubs have long been discussed by EU member states as a further measure to outsource refugee protection. A new Briefing shows, that they are legally fragile.

Equal Rights Beyond Borders consists of two separately registered legal entities in Greece and Germany.

Greece
Civil Non-Profit Company (AMKE)
Akadimias 84, 10678, Athens
+30 210 3803067, athens@equal-rights.org

Tax No.: GR 996887928, Tax Office: KEFODE Attikis
Registry No. (GEMI): 151850501000
NGO Registry No.: ID 3058

Germany
Gemeinnütziger Verein (e.V.)
Gerichtstraße 23, 13347 Berlin
info@equal-rights.org

Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg
VR 35583 B